Deutsche Tageszeitung - US top court: photographer cheated over Warhol print of Prince

US top court: photographer cheated over Warhol print of Prince


US top court: photographer cheated over Warhol print of Prince
US top court: photographer cheated over Warhol print of Prince / Photo: © AFP

The US Supreme Court ruled Thursday that a photographer was denied fair payment over the publication of an Andy Warhol print of the singer Prince, in a case with major implications for copyright law and the art world.

Change text size:

The court ruled that celebrity photographer Lynn Goldsmith should have earned a fee when the Andy Warhol Foundation licensed "Orange Prince," a silk screen print image of Prince, for use by Vanity Fair publisher Conde Nast.

There was no judgment against Warhol himself, who died in 1987.

Goldsmith was paid a one-time use fee of $400 in 1984 when Vanity Fair commissioned the artist to create a purple-tinted image of Prince that was based on one of her photos.

But after Prince died in 2016, Warhol's foundation licensed another image of the musician -- the "Orange Prince" -- that he had made from the same Goldsmith photo to Conde Nast.

The Foundation was paid $10,250 to license the image to Conde Nast, but Goldsmith got nothing.

She sued, claiming her copyright on the original photo was infringed.

In the high court's hearing on the case in October 2022, the Foundation argued in court that Warhol's work was "transformative" -- an original piece infused with a new meaning or message.

That, the Foundation said, was permitted under what is known as the "fair use" doctrine in copyright law.

Lisa Blatt, a lawyer for Goldsmith, disagreed, arguing that the initial payment for the photograph recognized her rights.

"Warhol got the picture in 1984 because Miss Goldsmith was paid and credited," Blatt said.

She said ruling against Goldsmith would "decimate" the art of photography by killing the photographer's incentive to create.

The Foundation, she said, is claiming that "Warhol is a creative genius who imbued other people's art with his own distinctive style."

But if the court accepts this, Blatt said, "Copyrights will be at the mercy of copycats."

The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 in Goldsmith's favor.

"Goldsmith's original works, like those of other photographers, are entitled to copyright protection, even against famous artists," wrote Justice Sonia Sotomayor in the majority opinion.

"Such protection includes the right to prepare derivative works that transform the original," she wrote.

The court held that fair use of an image or other work of art is acceptable if the use "has a purpose and character that is sufficiently distinct from the original."

In the "Orange Prince" case, however, both Goldsmith and the Andy Warhol Foundation had the same commercial purpose in the licensing of the image, it said.

(M.Dorokhin--DTZ)

Featured

Tom Jones to Headline Forest Live at Cannock Chase in June

Legendary Welsh singer Tom Jones has been confirmed to headline the 2027 edition of Forest Live at Forestry England’s Cannock Chase. The 86-year-old performer will take the stage on Friday, June 25, marking his third appearance as a headliner for the popular music series.

Prague’s Concert for the Future Kicks Off on Wenceslas Square

The eleventh edition of the Concert for the Future (Koncert pro budoucnost) began Tuesday evening on Prague’s Wenceslas Square. Organized by the Nerudný fest association, the event features more than five hours of musical performances and cultural reflections to mark the Day of the Struggle for Freedom and Democracy.

'She Was a Monster': The Complex Reality of Patricia Highsmith Beyond the Ripley Myth

As a new film starring Helen Mirren examines the final years of Patricia Highsmith, former colleagues recall an author defined by contradictions. While remembered for her misanthropy and prejudice, those who knew her describe a complex figure whose sharp intellect and literary precision ensured her enduring legacy despite her personal unpopularity in America.

Shruti Haasan Reveals Kamal Haasan’s Defense of Her Film Career

Actor Shruti Haasan has revealed the personal reasoning behind her father Kamal Haasan’s support for her career in cinema. In a recent conversation with her cousin Suhasini Maniratnam, Shruti recalled how Kamal Haasan defended her choice to follow in his footsteps by drawing a parallel to the uncertainties of arranged marriage.

Change text size: