Deutsche Tageszeitung - Texas judge briefly lifts abortion ban for medical emergencies

Texas judge briefly lifts abortion ban for medical emergencies


Texas judge briefly lifts abortion ban for medical emergencies

A court in Texas on Friday issued a temporary order siding with a group of women and doctors who brought a lawsuit challenging the state's abortion bans.

Change text size:

The ruling was stayed hours later, however, after the Texas attorney general's office filed an appeal. Judge Jessica Mangrum's decision has been blocked until the lawsuit is decided on its merits in a trial slated to begin next March.

The case, which was filed by the Center for Reproductive Rights, argued that the way medical exceptions are defined under Texas law is confusing, stoking fear among doctors and causing a "health crisis."

In her judgment, Mangrum wrote she agreed the women were "delayed or denied access to abortion care because of the widespread uncertainty regarding physicians' level of discretion under the medical exception to Texas's abortion bans."

She ordered that physicians cannot be prosecuted for exercising their "good faith judgment."

Instead, doctors should be allowed to determine what they felt constituted medical emergencies that would risk a woman's "life and/or health (including their fertility)," she said.

First Assistant Attorney General Brent Webster said in a statement that the state filed an appeal that "stays an activist Austin judge's attempt to override Texas abortion laws pending a ruling by the Texas Supreme Court."

The court in Austin heard harrowing testimony from the plaintiffs last month.

Amanda Zurawski, after whom the case is named, said she was denied an abortion despite her water breaking very early in her pregnancy, meaning a miscarriage was inevitable.

Zurawski said her doctor told her that she "couldn't intervene, because the baby's heart was still beating and inducing labor would have been considered an illegal abortion."

Zurawski went into life-threatening septic shock and the fetus was stillborn.

The suit is the first brought on behalf of women denied abortions since the US Supreme Court overturned the constitutional right to the procedure just over a year ago.

Texas physicians found guilty of providing abortions face up to 99 years in prison, fines of up to $100,000 and the revocation of their medical license.

A state "trigger" ban went into effect when Roe v. Wade was overturned in June 2022, prohibiting abortions even in cases of rape or incest. Texas also has a law that allows private citizens to sue anyone who performs or aids an abortion.

The lawsuit asks the court to create a binding interpretation of the "medical emergency" exception in the law and argues physicians should be allowed to exercise "good faith" judgments on the qualifying conditions for an abortion, rather than leaving this to state lawmakers.

The Texas attorney general's office, on the other hand, says the measures sought by the complaint would effectively nullify its bans.

The medical exception proposed by the plaintiffs "would, by design, swallow the rule," its lawyers argued in their written response.

"It would, for example, permit abortions for pregnant females with medical conditions ranging from a headache to feelings of depression."

(N.Loginovsky--DTZ)

Featured

Emergency Doctors Warn Hospitals Cannot Guarantee Patient Safety This Winter

The Irish Association for Emergency Medicine (IAEM) has issued a stark warning that many hospitals are nearing breaking point and cannot guarantee patient safety as the winter season begins. The association criticized the normalization of treating patients in corridors, stating it must never be accepted as a cost of balancing budgets, while the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation highlighted critical staffing shortages.

Outdated Marriage Beliefs Hide Sexual Abuse Among Older South Africans

Deeply rooted cultural beliefs that marriage grants automatic sexual rights are leaving many older South Africans unable to recognize sexual abuse within their relationships. Recent workshops in Gauteng have highlighted how these outdated norms, combined with shame and financial dependence, prevent victims from seeking help or understanding consent.

RCSI President Calls for Enhanced Surgical Research Support at Millin Meeting

Professor Michael Kerin, president of the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI), has called for increased support for surgeons to strengthen the nation's surgical research capacity. His remarks preceded the annual Millin Meeting, a gathering of leading healthcare experts focused on integrating innovation and clinical trials into everyday surgical practice.

Toddler Diagnosed With Leukemia After Symptoms Dismissed as Winter Illness

Manraj Singh Hans, now seven, was diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in February 2023 after a prolonged period during which his early symptoms were repeatedly misdiagnosed as common infections. His parents, Narinder Singh and Parm Hans, initially dismissed signs of illness as winter fatigue before blood in the child’s diaper prompted urgent medical intervention.

Change text size: