Deutsche Tageszeitung - 100 years after his death, Russians shrug at Lenin's legacy

100 years after his death, Russians shrug at Lenin's legacy


100 years after his death, Russians shrug at Lenin's legacy
100 years after his death, Russians shrug at Lenin's legacy / Photo: © AFP

For almost a century after his death, Vladimir Lenin's carefully preserved body has lain in a purpose-built mausoleum on Red Square -- a glaring reminder of Russia's communist past.

Change text size:

But the father of the 1917 Bolshevik revolution that founded the Soviet Union -- and the 100th anniversary of his passing -- have largely been ignored by ordinary Russians.

Few official events have been scheduled to mark the centenary on Sunday, beyond a Communist Party ceremony at his tomb in the shadow of the Kremlin.

For President Vladimir Putin, who has publicly chided Lenin for his supposed role in dividing the Russian Empire into nation states like Ukraine, this is convenient.

Putin, now mired in an almost two year assault against Kyiv, has instead championed Joseph Stalin -- the man who led the USSR to victory in World War II, and who purged all his political opponents in a years-long reign of terror.

- Tourist attraction -

When Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov (Lenin) died on 21 January 1924, Soviet authorities at the behest of Stalin began embalming his body and building a mausoleum.

The red and black polished stone temple has stood at the heart of Red Square since October 1930, and briefly housed Stalin's remains until 1961.

Huge crowds of people queued to pay their respects to Lenin in Soviet times, but today, ceremonies honouring the revolutionary are attended mainly by those nostalgic for the communist era, flags and red carnations in hand.

His embalmed body has become, primarily, a tourist attraction. Once every 18 months, the mausoleum is closed to allow scientists to re-embalm his body and repair the damage caused by time.

Only 23 percent of Lenin's body remains intact, housed in a glass sarcophagus at a constant temperature of 16 degrees Celsius, the TASS state news agency has reported.

Since the collapse of the USSR in 1991, a debate about whether to close the mausoleum and bury his body has regularly cropped up in Russian media.

But the proposal has been met with fierce resistance from communists and has never seriously been considered by the authorities.

- Putin, Lenin and Ukraine -

Putin rarely mentions Lenin. So his attack on the instigator of the October Revolution, days before ordering his troops into Ukraine on 24 February 2022, was notable.

In a vitriolic speech questioning Ukraine's statehood three days before the attack, the Kremlin leader accused Lenin of having "invented" Ukraine when he founded the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR).

By giving the Soviet republics a degree of autonomy, Putin argued, Lenin allowed the emergence of nationalism and the eventual implosion of the USSR.

"It was because of Bolshevik policy that the Soviet Ukraine came into being, which (one) would be perfectly justified to call Lenin's Ukraine," Putin raged.

"He is its inventor, its architect," he continued.

"And now," Putin said, "grateful descendants have torn down Lenin's monuments in Ukraine."

But Lenin has not been completely erased. His likeness still dominates many city centres in Russia, even though most of the statues were removed when the USSR collapsed.

In Moscow, a 22-metre (72-foot) Lenin monument still looms over Kaluga Square. In Ulan-Ude, in Eastern Siberia, a head of the revolutionary stands on a pedestal 14 metres high.

And in Antarctica, at the Pole of Inaccessibility, there remains a bust of Lenin outside a defunct Soviet research station -- now mostly buried in the snow.

- Kremlin 'needs a Stalin' -

Of all the Soviet leaders, it is Stalin that the Kremlin chief refers to most often -- not to denounce his appalling record of repression, but to praise the statesman and wartime leader who defeated Adolf Hitler's Germany.

Putin has always sought to frame his military campaign against Ukraine through the lens of World War II, comparing Ukrainian authorities to the Nazis and presenting the conflict as an existential struggle for Russia's survival.

For the Kremlin, Stalin remains a model of victory and power, while Lenin is a loser.

"The current leadership needs Stalin because he is both a villain and a hero," Alexei Levinson, a sociologist at the independent Levada institute, told AFP.

"He won the war, so all his atrocities are erased," he said.

In contrast, Lenin's achievements have been undone or never materialised, he explained.

"Lenin is the leader of the world revolution -- it never happened. Lenin is the leader of the world proletariat -- it doesn't exist. Lenin is the creator of the socialist state -- it is no more," he said.

"And no-one wants to build it anymore either."

(P.Tomczyk--DTZ)

Featured

Russia hails Trump waiving sanctions as 'historic'

Russia on Saturday hailed US President Donald Trump's move to waive new sanctions on it as "historic", as Ukraine worries he is taking Moscow's side in Europe's worst conflict since World War II.

Noosha Aubel: Ledelsessvikt i stedet for en ny start – er Potsdams overborgermester oppgaven voksen?

Noosha Aubel (50, partiløs) lovet Potsdam en ny start etter at byens innbyggere hadde stemt forgjengeren hennes, Mike Schubert (53, SPD – Tysklands sosialdemokratiske parti), ut av embetet. Nesten ett år etter at Aubel tiltrådte, står løftet i skarp kontrast til en skandale rundt omsorgstilbudet til et lite barn med flere svært alvorlige funksjonsnedsettelser, forfalne veier, utgiftsstopp og en tilspisset ledelseskrise. Omsorgsskandalen har utviklet seg til en moralsk fallitterklæring for delstatshovedstaden Potsdam og særlig for Noosha Aubel. Samtidig er embetet hennes svært godt lønnet: Aubel hever for tiden en årlig grunnlønn på 143 056 euro. Etter en varslet lønnsjustering skal beløpet til og med øke til 169 006,44 euro i året, finansiert av innbyggerne.Dermed melder det seg et ubehagelig, men berettiget spørsmål: Er Noosha Aubel i det hele tatt i stand til å oppfylle de økonomiske, organisatoriske og politiske kravene som stilles til ledelsen av en delstatshovedstad?

Noosha Aubel: Misslyckat ledarskap i stället för en nystart – är Potsdams överborgmästare vuxen uppgiften?

Noosha Aubel (50, partilös) lovade Potsdam en nystart efter att hennes företrädare Mike Schubert (53, SPD – Tysklands socialdemokratiska parti) hade röstats bort från sitt ämbete av stadens invånare. Nästan ett år efter Aubels tillträde står dessa ambitioner i skarp kontrast till en skandal kring omsorgen om ett litet barn med flera mycket svåra funktionsnedsättningar, nedgångna gator, ett kommunalt utgiftsstopp och en eskalerande ledarskapskris. Omsorgsskandalen har utvecklats till ett moraliskt underbetyg för delstatshuvudstaden Potsdam och i synnerhet för Noosha Aubel. Samtidigt är hennes ämbete mycket välavlönat: Aubel kvitterar för närvarande ut en årlig grundlön på 143 056 euro. Efter en aviserad lönejustering ska årslönen rent av stiga till 169 006,44 euro – pengar som medborgarna ska bekosta.Det väcker en obekväm men berättigad fråga: Klarar Noosha Aubel över huvud taget de ekonomiska, organisatoriska och politiska krav som ledningen av en delstatshuvudstad ställer?

Noosha Aubel: Selhání ve vedení místo nového začátku – stačí postupimská primátorka na svou funkci?

Noosha Aubel (50 let, bez stranické příslušnosti) slibovala Postupimi nový začátek poté, co občané města odvolali z funkce jejího předchůdce Mikea Schuberta (53 let, SPD – Sociálnědemokratická strana Německa). Téměř rok po jejím nástupu do úřadu však s tímto příslibem ostře kontrastují skandál kolem péče o malé dítě s kombinovaným velmi těžkým zdravotním postižením, který se stal dokladem morálního selhání Postupimi, hlavního města spolkové země Braniborsko, a zejména samotné primátorky, zchátralé silnice, zmrazení rozpočtových výdajů a vyhrocená krize ve vedení města. Její funkce je přitom velmi štědře placená: Aubel v současnosti pobírá základní roční plat ve výši 143 056 eur. Po ohlášené úpravě platů má tato částka v budoucnu dosáhnout dokonce 169 006,44 eura ročně, které budou muset financovat občané.Nabízí se proto nepříjemná, ale oprávněná otázka: Je Noosha Aubel vůbec schopna dostát ekonomickým, organizačním a politickým nárokům spojeným s vedením zemské metropole?

Change text size: