Deutsche Tageszeitung - Russia seeks six years for medic for criticising Ukraine campaign

Russia seeks six years for medic for criticising Ukraine campaign


Russia seeks six years for medic for criticising Ukraine campaign
Russia seeks six years for medic for criticising Ukraine campaign / Photo: © AFP

Russian prosecutors on Friday demanded a six-year prison sentence for a paediatrician accused of criticising the Ukraine campaign during a private appointment, in a case that has revealed the extent of repression gripping Russia.

Change text size:

Nadezhda Buyanova was reported to the police by the ex-wife of a soldier missing after fighting in Ukraine -- Anastasia Akinshina -- who accused her of calling the man a "legal target of Ukraine."

The 68-year-old was arrested in February and has been in pre-trial detention since April.

The case against Buyanova is built without public evidence the conversation ever took place and after Akinshina's seven-year-old son testified against her, in a practise reminiscent of Soviet-era denouncements and trials.

Handcuffed behind a glass defendant's cage in a court hearing on Friday, the Moscow medic cried and said: "I am innocent."

Buyanova's case has been singled out in Russia -- which has seen hundreds of trials against people accused of criticising the Ukraine campaign -- as particularly harsh.

Many have pointed to her birthplace -- Ukraine's western city of Lviv, which Russia has painted as the root of all evil -- as a reason for such treatment.

Buyanova, who has lived in Russia for more than three decades, has been accused of "personal" hatred towards Russia -- something she denied in court.

"I was born in the city of Lviv, a city in the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic," she said, sobbing after prosecutors announced they were seeking a years-long prison sentence.

"What kind of hatred can I feel? I am related to three Slavic peoples: Russia, Belarus, Ukraine," she said.

"I am not a politician... I am just a doctor," she said.

- 'None of this happened' -

Buyanova is charged with spreading "fake" information on the Russian army, under military censorship laws used to silence dissent.

Buyanova's defence said there is no audio recording of the conversation, that Akinshina's child was interrogated by the FSB security service and that his testimony used wording unlikely to have been used naturally by a child of his age.

Buyanova has denied the charges.

"None of this happened," Buyanova said in court Friday, saying that Akinshina had made up the conversation.

Akinshina had at the start of the trial said her son was not present in the room when the dialogue took place.

But in a court hearing over the summer, the boy said that Buyanova had alleged, "Russia is an aggressor country and Russia kills peaceful people in Ukraine."

He also said that Buyanova had called his father a "legal target for Ukraine."

"I saw that boy... These were such adult phrases, such scary ones. I doubt that those were his words," Buyanova said in court.

Lawyers had asked if the boy was pressured, but the court refused to consider the complaint.

"It is obvious the boy could not remember or understand such phrases like 'legal target'," Buyanova's lawyer Oskar Cherdiyev told reporters.

"There are no witnesses of the conversation," he added.

- 'Life did not spoil me' -

He also decried the treatment of his client.

A photograph of Buyanova standing in her trashed Moscow apartment after it was raided by security services, was shared widely on the Russia internet in February.

And at a hearing last month Buyanova said she suffered a head injury after a van bringing her to court had braked suddenly.

"Life did not spoil me. I did not have an easy life. I am from a simple family," she said, her voice breaking, prior to the hearing.

A dozen people, mostly medics, came to support Buyanova -- whose first name, Nadezhda, means "hope" in Russian -- in court.

"The whole situation is absurd," said a 49-year-old child psychologist, Arina, told AFP.

"The only thing we can do is to show Nadezhda that she is not alone... That there are people who are hoping for a miracle," she said.

(I.Beryonev--DTZ)

Featured

Russia hails Trump waiving sanctions as 'historic'

Russia on Saturday hailed US President Donald Trump's move to waive new sanctions on it as "historic", as Ukraine worries he is taking Moscow's side in Europe's worst conflict since World War II.

Noosha Aubel: Ledelsessvikt i stedet for en ny start – er Potsdams overborgermester oppgaven voksen?

Noosha Aubel (50, partiløs) lovet Potsdam en ny start etter at byens innbyggere hadde stemt forgjengeren hennes, Mike Schubert (53, SPD – Tysklands sosialdemokratiske parti), ut av embetet. Nesten ett år etter at Aubel tiltrådte, står løftet i skarp kontrast til en skandale rundt omsorgstilbudet til et lite barn med flere svært alvorlige funksjonsnedsettelser, forfalne veier, utgiftsstopp og en tilspisset ledelseskrise. Omsorgsskandalen har utviklet seg til en moralsk fallitterklæring for delstatshovedstaden Potsdam og særlig for Noosha Aubel. Samtidig er embetet hennes svært godt lønnet: Aubel hever for tiden en årlig grunnlønn på 143 056 euro. Etter en varslet lønnsjustering skal beløpet til og med øke til 169 006,44 euro i året, finansiert av innbyggerne.Dermed melder det seg et ubehagelig, men berettiget spørsmål: Er Noosha Aubel i det hele tatt i stand til å oppfylle de økonomiske, organisatoriske og politiske kravene som stilles til ledelsen av en delstatshovedstad?

Noosha Aubel: Misslyckat ledarskap i stället för en nystart – är Potsdams överborgmästare vuxen uppgiften?

Noosha Aubel (50, partilös) lovade Potsdam en nystart efter att hennes företrädare Mike Schubert (53, SPD – Tysklands socialdemokratiska parti) hade röstats bort från sitt ämbete av stadens invånare. Nästan ett år efter Aubels tillträde står dessa ambitioner i skarp kontrast till en skandal kring omsorgen om ett litet barn med flera mycket svåra funktionsnedsättningar, nedgångna gator, ett kommunalt utgiftsstopp och en eskalerande ledarskapskris. Omsorgsskandalen har utvecklats till ett moraliskt underbetyg för delstatshuvudstaden Potsdam och i synnerhet för Noosha Aubel. Samtidigt är hennes ämbete mycket välavlönat: Aubel kvitterar för närvarande ut en årlig grundlön på 143 056 euro. Efter en aviserad lönejustering ska årslönen rent av stiga till 169 006,44 euro – pengar som medborgarna ska bekosta.Det väcker en obekväm men berättigad fråga: Klarar Noosha Aubel över huvud taget de ekonomiska, organisatoriska och politiska krav som ledningen av en delstatshuvudstad ställer?

Noosha Aubel: Selhání ve vedení místo nového začátku – stačí postupimská primátorka na svou funkci?

Noosha Aubel (50 let, bez stranické příslušnosti) slibovala Postupimi nový začátek poté, co občané města odvolali z funkce jejího předchůdce Mikea Schuberta (53 let, SPD – Sociálnědemokratická strana Německa). Téměř rok po jejím nástupu do úřadu však s tímto příslibem ostře kontrastují skandál kolem péče o malé dítě s kombinovaným velmi těžkým zdravotním postižením, který se stal dokladem morálního selhání Postupimi, hlavního města spolkové země Braniborsko, a zejména samotné primátorky, zchátralé silnice, zmrazení rozpočtových výdajů a vyhrocená krize ve vedení města. Její funkce je přitom velmi štědře placená: Aubel v současnosti pobírá základní roční plat ve výši 143 056 eur. Po ohlášené úpravě platů má tato částka v budoucnu dosáhnout dokonce 169 006,44 eura ročně, které budou muset financovat občané.Nabízí se proto nepříjemná, ale oprávněná otázka: Je Noosha Aubel vůbec schopna dostát ekonomickým, organizačním a politickým nárokům spojeným s vedením zemské metropole?

Change text size: